Choosing the right smart home hub can be the difference between a setup that "just works" and one that needs constant troubleshooting. Three of the most discussed options — Amazon Echo Hub, Samsung SmartThings Hub, and Hubitat Elevation — take very different approaches to unifying Zigbee, Z-Wave, Wi-Fi, and Matter devices. The Echo Hub leans on Alexa and cloud convenience, SmartThings balances a friendly app with broad ecosystem support, and Hubitat Elevation prioritizes local, fast, private automation.
This comparison breaks down how each hub handles protocols, automation, offline behavior, ease of use, and long-term flexibility so you can pick the one that matches your priorities.
Quick comparison at a glance
Before diving into each hub, here's a side-by-side look at the three contenders. The table highlights the protocol support, automation engine, and whether the hub can keep running without an internet connection.
| Feature | Echo Hub (2023) | SmartThings Hub (2018) | Hubitat Elevation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Radios | Zigbee, Thread, Matter, Sidewalk, BLE | Zigbee, Z-Wave (plus internal backup battery) | Zigbee, Z-Wave |
| Voice assistant | Alexa built-in | Alexa and Google via linked accounts | Alexa and Google via community integrations |
| Automation engine | Alexa routines (cloud-leaning) | SmartApps (local and cloud) | Rule Machine and apps (fully local) |
| Works offline | Limited — depends on Alexa cloud | Partially — some automations local | Yes — fully local execution |
| Form factor | Wall-mount tablet with 8" touchscreen | Small puck with battery backup | Compact USB-powered box |
| Best for | Alexa-first households | Broad ecosystem, app users | Tinkerers and privacy-focused users |
Amazon Echo Hub (2023)
The Amazon Echo Hub is the most tablet-like of the three. For a full breakdown, see our Echo Hub (2023) review and our Echo Hub buying guide. It's an 8-inch wall-mounted control panel running Fire OS with Alexa built in, designed to sit at the center of an Alexa-first smart home. If you're also considering a larger wall-mounted smart display, our Echo Show 15 buying guide covers how it compares. Unlike a standard Echo speaker, the Hub includes Zigbee, Thread, Bluetooth, Sidewalk, and Matter radios, so it can directly pair a wide range of devices rather than relying solely on Wi-Fi.
Where the Echo Hub shines is simplicity. You log in with an Amazon account, and devices already linked to your Alexa account show up automatically. Dashboards can be customized with room tiles, camera feeds, and lighting groups, and you can trigger scenes by voice or touch. For households already invested in Alexa speakers, the Hub feels like a natural command center.
Key takeaway
The Echo Hub is a wall control panel first, a smart home hub second. It's excellent for Alexa households but less suited to advanced users who want deep local automation.
Protocol support and compatibility
The Echo Hub's radio stack is modern: Zigbee for lights and sensors, Thread and Matter for newer cross-platform devices, and Sidewalk for low-bandwidth outdoor sensors. Notably, it does not include Z-Wave, which is a significant limitation if you have existing Z-Wave locks, sensors, or thermostats. You can still control those devices if they're linked through a compatible skill or Matter bridge, but direct pairing isn't possible.
Automation capabilities
Automations run through Alexa Routines. These are easy to set up in the app — triggers like time, location, device state, or a spoken phrase can activate scenes. However, many routines still depend on the Alexa cloud for evaluation, meaning an internet outage can interrupt them. The Hub does support local execution for some Matter and Zigbee devices, but it's not a blanket guarantee.
Pros
- Clean 8-inch touchscreen dashboard for wall mounting
- Modern radios including Matter, Thread, and Sidewalk
- Tight Alexa integration with built-in voice control
- Simple onboarding for existing Alexa households
Cons
- No Z-Wave support out of the box
- Routines lean on the cloud and may fail without internet
- Less flexible for complex, conditional automations
- Tablet UI can feel limited compared to dedicated apps
Samsung SmartThings Hub (2018, 3rd Gen)
The Samsung SmartThings Hub (3rd Gen) is the older-but-still-relevant choice of the three. For a full breakdown, see our SmartThings Hub (3rd Gen) review and our SmartThings buying guide. It's a small puck-shaped hub that includes both Zigbee and Z-Wave radios, a USB port for local storage, and an internal battery backup that keeps it running briefly during a power outage. It doesn't have a screen, so you control it entirely through the SmartThings mobile app.
SmartThings has historically been the "middle ground" hub: more flexible than a voice-assistant-only setup, but easier to use than a tinkerer platform like Hubitat. The app supports a wide range of devices directly, and SmartThings' cloud-to-cloud integrations cover hundreds of brands that don't have Zigbee or Z-Wave versions.
Protocol support and compatibility
With both Zigbee and Z-Wave on board, the SmartThings Hub can pair directly with the majority of mainstream smart home devices, including locks, motion sensors, leak detectors, and smart plugs. Samsung has also pushed the platform toward Matter, though the 2018 hub's Matter support comes via a software update and is more limited than newer hubs. For a deeper look at the hardware, see our Samsung SmartThings Hub GP-U999SJVLGDA review. Devices connected through "Works with SmartThings" cloud integrations don't require a hub radio at all, which is convenient but adds cloud dependency.
Automation capabilities
SmartThings uses SmartApps and Scenes for automation. Routines can trigger on device state, time, mode, or location, and the newer SmartThings app includes a more visual routine builder. Some automations run locally on the hub, particularly those involving Zigbee or Z-Wave device-to-device rules, while cloud-connected devices require an internet connection. Custom code and community SmartApps are more restricted than they once were, so power users may find the platform less hackable than it used to be.
Pros
- Built-in Zigbee and Z-Wave radios cover most devices
- Battery backup keeps the hub online briefly during outages
- Broad cloud-to-cloud integrations for many brands
- Friendly app with visual routine builder
Cons
- 2018 hardware is aging and Matter support is limited
- Cloud-connected devices won't work offline
- Custom SmartApps have been increasingly restricted
- No screen or built-in voice assistant
Hubitat Elevation Local Smart Home Hub
The Hubitat Elevation is built for a very different audience. To learn more, see our Hubitat Elevation buying guide. It's a compact, USB-powered box with Zigbee and Z-Wave radios, and its defining feature is that everything runs locally. There's no required cloud account, and automations execute on the hub itself, which makes them fast, reliable, and private. The trade-off is a steeper learning curve and a web-based interface that prioritizes function over polish.
Hubitat appeals to users who want to escape cloud dependencies, avoid subscription fees, and have fine-grained control over every rule. It's common among people who have outgrown SmartThings or who want their home to keep working during an internet outage.
Who it's for
If you value speed, privacy, and offline reliability over a glossy app experience, Hubitat is the strongest of the three. Expect to spend time learning its interface.
Protocol support and compatibility
Hubitat Elevation includes both Zigbee and Z-Wave, so it pairs directly with the same broad device families SmartThings supports. It doesn't include Thread or Matter natively, though community integrations and bridges can connect those devices. The hub also integrates with Alexa and Google Assistant through Hubitat's cloud relay, letting you voice-control locally paired devices without exposing them to the voice assistant directly.
Automation capabilities
This is where Hubitat pulls ahead. The built-in Rule Machine is a powerful conditional engine that can handle complex logic — nested conditions, variables, time windows, device-to-device triggers, and custom actions. Apps written by the community extend functionality further, covering everything from presence detection to thermostat scheduling. Because automations run on the hub, response times are typically measured in milliseconds rather than the seconds a cloud-based routine can take.
Pros
- Fully local execution for fast, reliable automations
- No subscription fees and no mandatory cloud account
- Zigbee and Z-Wave support for direct device pairing
- Rule Machine enables complex conditional logic
- Works with Alexa and Google via optional relay
Cons
- Web interface is utilitarian and not beginner-friendly
- Steeper learning curve for Rule Machine and apps
- No Thread or Matter support out of the box
- No touchscreen or built-in voice assistant
How they compare on the details that matter
Local vs. cloud behavior
If a fully offline-capable home is a priority, Hubitat is the clear winner. SmartThings runs some automations locally but still depends on the cloud for many devices and the app itself. The Echo Hub relies most heavily on the Alexa cloud, and its routines can stop responding during outages even if paired Zigbee devices remain online.
Ecosystem and voice assistant
The Echo Hub is the obvious pick for Alexa-centric households because voice control is built in and there's no account linking required. SmartThings works with both Alexa and Google Assistant but requires linking accounts and routing through the cloud. Hubitat supports both voice assistants through its cloud relay, but setup takes a few extra steps.
Device compatibility
SmartThings and Hubitat both include Z-Wave, which the Echo Hub lacks. If you have Z-Wave locks, sensors, or thermostats, that tips the balance away from Amazon. On the other hand, the Echo Hub's Matter and Thread support makes it more future-proof for newer cross-platform devices.
Ease of use
For a non-technical household, the Echo Hub is the easiest to set up and use day to day, thanks to the touchscreen and Alexa integration. SmartThings sits in the middle with a polished app. Hubitat rewards technical users but can frustrate beginners who expect a guided setup.
Amazon Echo Hub — built-in voice, touchscreen dashboard, and seamless Amazon account integration.
Samsung SmartThings — Zigbee and Z-Wave plus extensive cloud-to-cloud integrations.
Hubitat Elevation — fully local execution with Rule Machine for complex, fast automations.
Hubitat Elevation — keeps automations running even with no internet connection.
Which hub should you choose?
The right choice depends less on raw specs and more on how you want to interact with your smart home. If you want a wall-mounted panel that responds to "Alexa, goodnight" and controls your lights, locks, and cameras in one place, the Echo Hub is the most natural fit — provided you don't need Z-Wave.
If you want a balance of broad compatibility, a friendly app, and decent automation without committing to a single voice assistant, SmartThings remains a solid middle-ground option, though the 2018 hardware is starting to show its age against newer Matter-ready hubs.
If you want your home to run fast, privately, and reliably without depending on someone else's cloud, Hubitat Elevation is the strongest choice. You'll invest more time upfront, but the payoff is a system that keeps working no matter what happens to your internet connection.
Overall recommendation
For most users who already live in an Alexa ecosystem, the Amazon Echo Hub offers the best combination of usability and modern protocol support. For advanced users who prioritize local control and complex automations, Hubitat Elevation is the superior long-term platform. SmartThings sits between them and remains a reasonable choice for households that want both Zigbee and Z-Wave without the Hubitat learning curve.
Pricing and availability may change. As an affiliate we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Echo Hub support Z-Wave?
No. The Echo Hub includes Zigbee, Thread, Matter, Sidewalk, and Bluetooth, but it does not have a Z-Wave radio. Z-Wave devices can only be used if they're bridged through another compatible system.
Can SmartThings work without internet?
Partially. Automations involving directly paired Zigbee or Z-Wave devices can run locally, but cloud-connected devices and the mobile app require an internet connec
![SmartThings Hub 3rd Generation [GP-U999SJVLGDA] Smart Home Automation Hub Home Monitoring Smart Devices - Alexa Google Home Compatible - Zigbee, Z-Wave, Cloud to Cloud Protocols – White - Amazon.com](https://homesystemsguide-images.s3.amazonaws.com/managed-images/samsung-smartthings-hub-2018-3rd-gen-ce7289a0_10.jpg)